What is deficiency in a short sale?

Deficiency is the difference between what you owe on your mortgage and what the lender receives from the short sale after all costs. For example, if you owe $300,000 and the lender nets $250,000, the deficiency is $50,000.

Is short sale better than foreclosure?

Generally yes. A short sale typically has less impact on your credit score (100-150 points vs 200-300 for foreclosure), allows you to buy another home sooner (2-4 years vs 5-7 years), and may result in less deficiency debt. However, each situation is unique.

Do I have to pay taxes on forgiven debt?

Forgiven debt may be considered taxable income by the IRS. However, there are exceptions including insolvency and the Mortgage Forgiveness Debt Relief Act for primary residences. Consult a tax professional for your specific situation.

Short Sale Calculator

Calculate your short sale deficiency, net proceeds, and compare with foreclosure to make an informed decision.

Short Sale Deficiency Calculator

Estimate your short sale outcome and compare with foreclosure

Current Mortgage Details

1st Mortgage Balance ($) Current balance on primary mortgage

2nd Mortgage / HELOC ($) Other liens on property

Other Liens ($) Tax liens, HOA liens, judgments

Months Behind on Payments Number of missed payments

Property & Sale Details

Current Market Value ($) Estimated property value

Proposed Sale Price ($) Expected short sale price

Agent Commission (%) Real estate agent fees

Closing Costs ($) Title, escrow, other fees

Tax Information (Optional)

Your Tax Bracket (%) Federal income tax bracket

Property Type Affects tax treatment

Short Sale Analysis

⚠

Important Disclaimer

This calculator provides estimates only. Consult with a real estate attorney, tax professional, and your lender before proceeding with a short sale.

Total Deficiency

Shortfall amount

Total Owed

All debts + arrears

Net to Lender

After sale costs

Lender Recovery

Of total owed

Debt vs Recovery

Total Owed

Recovered

Recovered: $0 Deficiency: $0

Short Sale Impact

100-150 pts

Credit score drop

Buy Again (Short Sale)

2-4 Years

Wait to qualify

Foreclosure Impact

200-300 pts

Credit score drop

Sale Proceeds Distribution

To Lender (0%)

Commission (0%)

Closing (0%)

Short Sale Breakdown

1st Mortgage Balance $0

2nd Mortgage / HELOC $0

Other Liens $0

Back Payments Owed $0

                    Total Owed
                    $0
                

Sale Price $0

Less: Agent Commission -$0

Less: Closing Costs -$0

                    Net to Lender
                    $0
                

Deficiency (Shortfall) $0

Short Sale vs Foreclosure Comparison

Factor	Short Sale	Foreclosure	Better Option
Credit Impact	100-150 points	200-300 points	Short Sale
Credit Report	7 years	7 years	Same
Buy Home Again	2-4 years	5-7 years	Short Sale
Deficiency Judgment	Possible	Possible	Same
Control Over Process	More control	Less control	Short Sale
Estimated Deficiency	$0	$0	-

Potential Tax Implications

Forgiven Debt (1099-C)

May be reported to IRS

Potential Tax Liability

At 22% bracket

Primary Residence Exclusion

May Apply

Consult tax professional

Insolvency Exception

May Apply

If liabilities exceed assets

Deficiency Calculation

Deficiency = Total Owed - (Sale Price - Costs)

Understanding Short Sales

What is a Short Sale?

A short sale occurs when a homeowner sells their property for less than the total amount owed on the mortgage. The lender agrees to accept less than full payment to avoid the lengthy and costly foreclosure process. This option is typically available to homeowners facing financial hardship.

Short Sale Requirements

Financial hardship (job loss, medical, divorce, etc.)
Property value less than mortgage balance
No assets to pay the difference
Mortgage is in or near default
Lender approval required

Advantages of Short Sale

Less credit damage than foreclosure
May avoid deficiency judgment
Shorter wait to buy again
More control over the process
Less stressful than foreclosure

Important Considerations

Tax implications: Forgiven debt may be taxable
Deficiency rights: Vary by state
Timeline: Can take 3-6 months or longer
Credit impact: Still significant but less severe
Professional help: Consider attorney and CPA